Agentic commerce is about to answer a question direct selling has been circling for ninety years. Can a paid recommendation survive a suspicious customer? The most famous direct seller in history already told us no.
The interesting question about agents and commerce isn’t whether they’ll sell us things. They will. It’s what kind of seller they will turn out to be, because we have a century of sellers to compare them to, and the comparison could break in a direction almost nobody is talking about.
The agent isn’t the next influencer. On the part of selling that actually scales, the agent is the influencer’s opposite. It’s the anti-influencer. And whether the agentic commerce everyone is racing to build holds together or loses the user’s trust comes down to which of those two things the AI agent decides to be.
Splitting the Sale in Two
Let’s examine what a seller actually does, because agents are about to split those functions in two. And I’d like to start with the original sales model, the direct seller. Or in today’s vocabulary, the influencer.
A direct seller did two jobs at once, and we never had to separate them because they lived in the same person. The first is discovery and persuasion. “Let me tell you about something you didn’t know you wanted.” The second is transaction and trust. “Buy it through me, I’ll handle it.” Eons ago, in the physical world, the Avon lady did both across a kitchen table. The social media influencer does both inside a feed, the affiliate link standing in for the order form. The ad-supported platform does it too.
Agents pull the two functions apart. And once they’re apart they have completely different futures.
On the transaction side, the agent is the most complete direct seller ever built. It reaches everyone, it never sleeps, it closes without friction and it can be paid. Whoever compensates the agent, whether it’s the merchant through a take rate or the platform through placement, is writing the same check Avon wrote its reps. The commission framework is the same. Top-of-wallet becomes top-of-agent. This part of the model doesn’t go away. It gets sharper.
The discovery side of the model is where the agent-as-influencer comparison could fall apart.
Read More: The Pink Skirt Problem: Why AI Agents Can’t Own Serendipity
What the Influencer Actually Is
What’s old is new again. The influencer economy is direct selling rebuilt on platforms. LTK, ShopMy, the TikTok promo code. Same commission, new channel. But there’s one difference that turns out to be everything. The influencer still pitches the product. The entire …
Related
Leave a Reply